Compare broken?

A worn studded leather shirt and darkened platemail protect you roughly equally against piercing attacks. A worn studded leather shirt should give better protection against blunt attacks than darkened platemail. A worn studded leather shirt should give better protection against slashing attacks than darkened platemail. A worn studded leather shirt should give better protection against the elements than darkened platemail. You stop using darkened platemail. You wear a worn studded leather shirt on your body. Darkened platemail and a worn studded leather shirt protect you roughly equally against piercing attacks. Darkened platemail should give better protection against blunt attacks than a worn studded leather shirt. Darkened platemail should give better protection against slashing attacks than a worn studded leather shirt. Darkened platemail should give better protection against the elements than a worn studded leather shirt.